Bar Soap vs Body Wash: An Honest Comparison
Bar soap and body wash do the same job. The differences are in the format, not in whether you end up clean.
Packaging
A bar usually comes in paper or card. Body wash comes in a plastic bottle, often with a pump. If you are trying to cut down on plastic in the bathroom, this is the easy win.
How long they last
Body wash is mostly water, and it is easy to pour out more than you need. A bar is concentrated, and a well-kept bar lasts a long time. The catch is storage: a bar left in a puddle dissolves quickly.
Travel
A bar is solid, so it does not count as a liquid in hand luggage and cannot leak in a bag.
Lather
Body wash lathers instantly with a sponge. A bar lathers well too, especially with a washcloth, but the lather feels different: creamier and less foamy.
Ingredients
True soap is made from oils and lye. Most body washes are made with synthetic cleansers in a water base, with thickeners and preservatives to keep that water stable. Neither is automatically better. If you have sensitive skin, read the ingredient list of whichever you choose and avoid the fragrance or ingredient you react to.
Hygiene
People sometimes worry that a shared bar is unhygienic. Rinse the bar before and after use and let it dry between showers.
How to choose
- Choose a bar if you want less plastic, something that travels well and a simple ingredient list.
- Choose body wash if you prefer a quick foam and do not want to think about a soap dish.
More on the format in the bar soap comeback, and on how bars are made in how bar soap is made.