Honey vs Maple Syrup: Taste, Cooking and Storage Compared
Honey and maple syrup sit side by side in the cupboard and are often swapped for each other. They are quite different products.
Where they come from
- Honey is made by bees from flower nectar.
- Maple syrup is the sap of maple trees, collected in early spring and boiled down. It takes roughly 40 gallons of sap to make one gallon of syrup.
Taste
Honey is floral and varies enormously with the flowers the bees visited. Maple syrup tastes of caramel, vanilla and wood, and varies with the grade: golden is delicate, dark is robust.
Texture
Honey is thick and sticky. Maple syrup is thin and pours easily.
Sweetness and calories
Honey is the sweeter of the two, so you tend to need less. Per tablespoon, honey has about 64 calories and maple syrup about 52. Both are sugars.
In cooking and baking
- Honey browns faster and gives a chewier, moister result.
- Maple syrup is thinner, so it adds more liquid to a batter.
- In dressings, glazes and marinades you can usually swap them one for one and adjust to taste.
Storage
This is the biggest practical difference. Honey keeps at room temperature indefinitely. Maple syrup must be refrigerated once opened, or it can grow mould.
Who each one suits
Maple syrup is plant-based, so it suits a vegan diet. Honey should never be given to infants under one year old.
Which should you use?
Maple for pancakes and anything that wants a caramel note. Honey for tea, dressings, marinades and baking that should stay soft. More in how to substitute honey for sugar in baking.