Honey vs Sugar: How They Differ in the Kitchen
Honey and sugar both sweeten, but they behave very differently in a recipe. Knowing how saves a lot of flat cakes and burnt glazes.
What they are
Table sugar is pure sucrose in dry crystals. Honey is a liquid: roughly 80 percent sugars, mainly fructose and glucose, and about 17 to 18 percent water, plus the compounds that give each honey its flavour.
Sweetness
Honey tastes sweeter than sugar, so recipes need less of it. A common starting point is two thirds to three quarters of a cup of honey for each cup of sugar.
Calories per spoon
A tablespoon of honey has about 64 calories. A tablespoon of sugar has about 48. Honey is denser, so a spoonful weighs more, but because it is sweeter you generally use less. Both are sugars.
Moisture
Honey adds liquid and also holds on to moisture. Bakes made with honey are softer and stay fresh longer. They are also less crisp, so honey is not the best choice for a snappy biscuit.
Browning
Honey browns faster than sugar. Lower the oven by about 25°F and watch the last few minutes.
Flavour
Sugar is neutral. Honey brings its own flavour, from barely there to bold, depending on the variety.
Acidity
Honey is slightly acidic. In baking, a pinch of baking soda balances it and helps the rise.
When to use which
- Honey: dressings, marinades, glazes, drinks, soft cakes, quick breads, granola.
- Sugar: meringues, crisp cookies, and anything that depends on creaming butter and sugar for lift.
The full method is in how to substitute honey for sugar in baking.